Viewing cable 08PARIS2190
Title: IEA Standing Group on Emergency Questions, November 2008

IdentifierCreatedReleasedClassificationOrigin
08PARIS21902008-12-03 13:09:00 2011-08-30 01:44:00 UNCLASSIFIED Embassy Paris
P 031309Z DEC 08
FM AMEMBASSY PARIS
TO SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 4957
INFO OECD POSTS COLLECTIVE
AMEMBASSY LJUBLJANA 
AMEMBASSY MOSCOW 
AMEMBASSY SANTIAGO 
AMEMBASSY TALLINN 
AMEMBASSY TEL AVIV 
AMEMBASSY BEIJING 
AMEMBASSY BRASILIA 
AMEMBASSY JAKARTA 
AMEMBASSY NEW DELHI 
AMEMBASSY PRETORIA
UNCLAS PARIS 002190 
 
 
DEPT PLEASE PASS TO DOE 
FROM USOECD 
 
E.O. 12958: N/A 
TAGS: ECON EFIN ENRG EPET IEA OECD
SUBJECT: IEA Standing Group on Emergency Questions, November 2008 
 
1)  SUMMARY:  The International Energy Agency (IEA) Standing Group 
on Emergency Questions (SEQ), the committee charged with maintaining 
IEA readiness to respond to oil supply emergencies, and the Standing 
Group on the Oil Market (SOM), the committee charged with oil market 
monitoring, met at IEA Headquarters in Paris on November 19-20, 
¶2008.  The two committees met in joint session on November 19, with 
the SEQ holding its own meeting on November 20.  The joint meeting 
on the 19th featured presentations by the IEA Secretariat on both 
the oil and gas markets.  The decline in oil prices has been largely 
driven by the global economic downturn and what that implies for 
global oil demand.  The IEA noted that this was a very unstable time 
in the oil market, with OPEC adding to uncertainty with its plans to 
cut output.  The joint meeting also featured a presentation by the 
UK on the upcoming London Energy Meeting.  Plans for the London 
meeting were still a work in progress; the morning session of the 
one-day meeting to focus on a CERA study on the financial crisis and 
its impacts on the energy market.  The SEQ discussed making public 
on a monthly basis member countries' days of stocks, as well as 
other pertinent information about members' stockholding measures. 
The SEQ also discussed implementing a series of workshops that could 
delve more deeply into issues that surface in the IEA's Emergency 
Response Exercises.  The SEQ is also playing a role in developing 
the IEA's policy toward natural gas security.  The U.S. delegation 
included Al Hegburg and Jim Hart of the Department of Energy, and 
Joel Kopp of the Department of State.  End Summary. 
 
JOINT MEETING - OIL AND GAS MARKETS 
--------------------------------------------- ---- 
 
2)  The IEA's conclusions on the state of the oil market are similar 
to other analysts', in that there has been unexpectedly slow 
economic growth and the sluggish oil market is based on the 
expectation that the economic outlook remains grim. IEA assumes 
China's economic growth will continue to provide some support for 
oil demand growth. Also of interest: new OPEC oil capacity coming on 
line in the next 12-18 months may be difficult to stop or slow this 
late in the development for the various projects. However, IEA would 
expect to see some "strategic stoppage" or slowing to occur with 
longer term planned projects if present market conditions continue. 
On gas, Norway tried to distance themselves from the upcoming Russia 
"gas OPEC" meeting, saying they would be sending only technical 
experts rather than political figures, and that their participation 
rises out of support for consumer-producer dialogues in general 
rather than out of likemindedness with all the potential gas OPEC 
participants. But they're still going. Also of note from gas market 
overview is that gas and electricity markets seem to becoming 
increasingly linked. 
 
JOINT MEETING - LONDON ENERGY MEETING 
--------------------------------------------- ----- 
 
3)  The UK is staging a follow-up to the Jeddah Energy Meeting in 
London on December 18-19.  The UK envisions a morning session 
consisting of a PM Brown welcoming statement and a plenary on 
financial markets and their impacts on energy markets and energy 
security, followed by an afternoon breakout session to examine 
progress made on Jeddah commitments. UK and the Saudis have jointly 
contracted with CERA to write the paper to be reviewed during the 
morning session; it will be circulated shortly before actual meeting 
(about a week ahead of time).  The purpose of the session won't be 
to draw conclusions but to highlight issues. There will be a UK 
Chair summary of the meeting. UK wants the process to focus on three 
overall themes: 1) better oil market transparency and data quality, 
2) energy efficiency and low emission technologies, and 3) barriers 
to investment and helping poor and developing countries with access 
to energy.  Germany's delegate pointed out this process should feed 
into the IEF; UK promised to keep IEF informed. Japan announced that 
their Energy Forum, which they had envisioned as feeding into this 
London meeting, had been "postponed" but hoped that the next G8 host 
would take up this G8 commitment. 
 
SEQ MEETING - MAKING MEMBERS' STOCK INFORMATION PUBLIC 
--------------------------------------------- --------- 
 
4)  This issue had been discussed at the SEQ's September meeting. 
The Secretariat has continued to modify and improve the pubic 
website it will launch which provides member countries' 
stockholdings and background information on each country's 
stockholding system.  The USG has spoken in favor of making this 
information public, as it will increase market knowledge of IEA 
capability, provide answers to many commonly asked questions, clear 
up some common misunderstandings among the public, and may provide 
additional incentive for countries to meet their 90-day obligation, 
as any failure to do so will be publicly documented on the website. 
Several members spoke in favor of the Secretariat continuing with 
its work on making the stocks data public. 
 
SEQ MEETING - FUTURE EXERCISES AND WORKSHOPS 
--------------------------------------------- 
 
5)  The Secretariat plans to continue with its biennial large-scale 
emergency response exercises in roughly the same format as the June 
2008 Emergency Response Exercise 4, which was roundly praised, 
believing that this provides an excellent training tool and 
refresher for member country representatives, as well as an 
excellent outreach tool for non-member countries. While there are 
other specific issues that also could be discussed during such 
exercises, the Secretariat believes that these could be better dealt 
with using smaller workshops with more limited attendance, likely 
adjacent to future SEQ meetings. Several members, including the USG, 
endorsed this approach. The first such workshop will be in response 
to a Governing Board directive to study the way stocks are released 
to the market during an IEA-coordinated draw-down. Practices, 
policies, and capabilities vary between members, and it will be 
useful to examine how such releases occur, what type of crude or 
product is released, when, and where (among other issues). This 
workshop may occur adjacent to the June 2009 SEQ meeting. 
 
SEQ MEETING - EMERGENCY POLICY FOR NATURAL GAS 
--------------------------------------------- -- 
 
6)  The SEQ and Secretariat, responding to a directive from the last 
meeting of IEA Ministers, continues to develop a framework paper on 
emergency policy for natural gas. Main options at this point seem to 
be enhancing market conditions to minimize the likelihood of 
significant market disruption, and individual countries developing a 
response system for disruptions based on their own needs and 
circumstances. Stockpiling natural gas, for the record, is 
complicated and costly (much more so than crude oil).  The SEQ 
supported the work represented in the Secretariat paper, which will 
be presented to the SLT and Governing Board in December, then 
finalized in time for presentation at the October 2009 Ministerial. 
 
Comment: it is becoming increasingly clear that individual 
countries, including the USG, will have to decide what the IEA's 
role in gas security will be, and since gas is closely related to 
electricity, this more or less includes some aspect of electricity 
security as well. Neither of these are mentioned or even 
contemplated in the IEP. 
 
SEQ - OTHER BUSINESS 
---------------------------------------- 
 
7)  All members of the IEA are currently meeting their 90-day 
stockholding obligation, something that does not happen very often, 
so this meeting did not feature the ritual castigation of members 
below the 90-day requirement.   The IEA has done a final evaluation 
of an emergency data questionnaire that was used in the in-capitals 
phase of ERE4, deeming it a success.  The questionnaire will 
continue to be used in the event of supply emergencies and will be 
tested in future exercises. The IEA is planning to hold an Emergency 
Response Exercise with Thailand, tentative date being May 2009.  The 
next meeting of the SEQ will be 24-26 March 2009. 
 
 
EGAN